Sinners Stands Tall Against Avengers Films in a Stunning Box Office Race2025
Sinners, a period horror movie set in 1930s Mississippi, was directed by Ryan Coogler, the man behind Creed and Black Panther. In order to open a juke joint in their hometown of Clarksdale, twin brothers Smoke and Stack (both portrayed by Michael B. Jordan) must contend with a terrifying vampire threat. The movie combines elements of classic horror, blues music, and historical drama to create a unique experience that has enthralled both critics and viewers. Sinners, which stars Wunmi Mosaku, Hailee Steinfeld, Delroy Lindo, and Jack O’Connell, tells a powerful story that is visceral and emotionally charged.
Oblivion Remastered
The Box Office Race: Sinners vs. Avengers
Two MCU movies, Captain America: Brave New World, which came out earlier in 2025, and Thunderbolts, which came out on May 2, 2025, were a serious threat to Sinners as it began its theatrical run. Marvel’s well-known brand, enormous budgets, and devoted fan bases were all factors in both movies. While Thunderbolts began with $76 million and was expected to reach $200 million by the end of its run, Captain America: Brave New World made $200.4 million domestically. Sinners, on the other hand, was an underdog—an original tale devoid of a franchise safety net or superhero heritage. Its performance, however, has been nothing short of remarkable.
Week-by-Week Breakdown
- Opening Weekend (April 18–20, 2025): Sinners debuted with $48 million domestically, stealing the top spot from A Minecraft Movie, which was in its third weekend. This opening was a record-breaker, surpassing all original films of the decade and earning an A CinemaScore, a rare feat for a horror film (though debated, as Aliens also holds this distinction). Meanwhile, Captain America: Brave New World had already crossed $200 million domestically by this point, setting a high bar for 2025 releases.
- Second Weekend (April 25–27, 2025): Sinners stunned the industry with a mere 4.9% drop, grossing $45.7 million domestically—the smallest second-weekend decline for any film opening above $40 million since Avatar in 2009 and the lowest ever for an R-rated horror title. This remarkable hold placed Sinners in elite company, alongside family-friendly hits like Shrek and The Lord of the Rings. By the end of its second weekend, Sinners had grossed $122.5 million domestically and $161.6 million worldwide, already nearing its break-even point.
- Third Weekend (May 2–4, 2025): As Thunderbolts entered the fray with a $76 million opening, Sinners continued its strong performance, earning $33 million domestically (a 28% drop) despite losing IMAX screens to the MCU newcomer. This was the best third weekend for a horror film, surpassing It’s $29.7 million. By this point, Sinners had grossed $179.7 million domestically and $250.8 million worldwide, overtaking Captain America: Brave New World to become the second-highest-grossing film of 2025 domestically, behind only A Minecraft Movie ($401 million).
- Fourth Weekend (May 9–11, 2025): Thunderbolts held the top spot with $33.1 million in its second weekend, but Sinners remained a powerhouse, grossing $21.1 million (a 33% drop) and crossing the $200 million domestic milestone. This achievement made Sinners only the fourth R-rated horror film to surpass $200 million domestically, joining It, The Exorcist, and It: Chapter Two. Its global total reached $288.7 million, with projections suggesting it would hit $300 million by mid-May.
Sinners’ Historic Milestones
Sinners has not only competed with Avengers films but has also carved out a place in box office history. Here are some of its key achievements:
- Top R-Rated Horror Film: Sinners is the 15th highest-grossing R-rated film domestically, surpassing Ted and ranking just below Logan. It’s also the fourth highest-grossing horror film domestically, behind It, The Exorcist, and A Quiet Place.
- Vampire Horror Dominance: Globally, Sinners is the highest-grossing vampire movie ever, outpacing classics like Interview with the Vampire and signaling a potential renaissance for the subgenre.
- Warner Bros. Success: Sinners ranks among Warner Bros.’ top 40 films, surpassing 2023’s Wonka. Alongside A Minecraft Movie, it has solidified Warner Bros.’ dominance in 2025, a turnaround for studio chiefs Pamela Abdy and Mike De Luca after earlier disappointments.
- Original Film Triumph: With a projected global gross of at least $330 million, Sinners is the biggest original horror film since A Quiet Place in 2018 (adjusted for inflation). It outgrosses Jordan Peele’s Get Out ($337 million adjusted) and is on par with Scream and Halloween.
Why Sinners Succeeds Where Others Falter
Sinners’ box office success is a testament to several key factors that have allowed it to stand tall against the MCU juggernaut:
1. Critical and Audience Acclaim
Sinners is one of the most praised films of 2025, with a 98% review from critics and a 97% rating from viewers on Rotten Tomatoes. Universal acclaim for Coogler’s directing, Jordan’s dual performance, and the film’s audacious storytelling is reflected in its Certified Fresh status and Verified Hot audience rating. Due to word-of-mouth, audiences have flocked to theatres for repeat viewings, while critics have referred to it as “bloody, sexy, and a must-see.”
2. Cultural Resonance
Sinners, which is set in the 1930s South, has a soundtrack that includes gospel, soul, and blues music and is firmly anchored in Black culture. In addition to appealing to white and Latino viewers, the film’s examination of prejudice, community, and resiliency strikes a chord with marginalised audiences, especially Black ones. Both its widespread appeal and its accurate depiction of historical and cultural themes have contributed to its enduring popularity.
3. Genre-Bending Innovation
By fusing aspects of a period drama, gangster thriller, and blues musical with vampire horror, Sinners subverts conventional horror clichés. Coogler was able to create a new, unpredictable story that, as he put it, is like “reading Salem’s Lot while listening to the best blues record” because he refused to rely on already-existing IP. In a world where franchises rule, this uniqueness has attracted viewers looking for something fresh.
4. Strategic Release and Marketing
By using premium IMAX screenings, which made up 20% of opening weekend sales, and purposefully ambiguous trailers that maintained the film’s surprises, Warner Bros. made the most of Sinners’ Easter weekend release. Its performance was further enhanced by the studio’s decision to resume 70mm IMAX screenings from May 15–21, 2025. Early doubts about the movie’s financial success were also dispelled by social media buzz from stars like Tom Cruise and Ben Stiller.
5. Low Drop-Offs and Repeat Viewings
Sinners’ ability to hold onto audiences is demonstrated by its record-breaking low second-weekend drop (4.9%) and steady holds (28% in week three and 33% in week four). Sinners has benefited from rewatches and growing audiences, which is uncommon for the genre and contrasts with many horror films that experience sharp drops in popularity after their premiere.
The Avengers’ Struggles: A Shifting Landscape
In 2025, the MCU has encountered difficulties, whereas Sinners has flourished. Despite earning $200.4 million at home, Captain America: Brave New World didn’t have the same cultural impact as its predecessors due to a lacklustre fan reception and mixed reviews. With a projected domestic total of about $200 million, Thunderbolts is one of the lower-grossing MCU films, even with a strong $76 million opening and an 88% Certified Fresh rating. Compared to previous Avengers films, it is less of an event movie due to its $180 million budget and dependence on lesser-known characters.
What Sinners’ Success Means for Hollywood
Sinners’ box office triumph is a game-changer for an industry that has increasingly prioritized franchises over original content. Here are some key takeaways:
- Original Films Can Still Win: Sinners has shown that well-crafted, original stories can compete with superhero blockbusters, even with high budgets and R-ratings. Its success could inspire studios to take risks on bold, non-IP projects, especially from visionary directors like Coogler.
- Diverse Stories Matter: The film’s appeal to Black, white, and Latino audiences underscores the demand for inclusive, culturally rich narratives. Studios may look to replicate Sinners’ formula by investing in diverse casts and stories that reflect underrepresented experiences.
- Horror’s Renaissance: Sinners’ dominance as a vampire film, alongside the success of Nosferatu and Interview with the Vampire on TV, suggests a renewed interest in horror, particularly vampire stories. This could lead to a wave of new horror projects, potentially with Coogler at the helm.
- Coogler’s Hollywood Power: With Sinners poised to gross over $330 million worldwide, Coogler has solidified his status as one of Hollywood’s most bankable directors. If he chooses to expand Sinners into a franchise—despite his initial standalone vision—Warner Bros. will likely grant him significant creative control.
Looking Ahead: Can Sinners Sustain Its Momentum?
Sinners has made $288.7 million globally as of May 16, 2025, and by the end of its fourth weekend, it is expected to have surpassed $300 million. The movie is in a good position to maintain its successful run because 70mm IMAX screenings are coming back and there won’t be much competition until Final Destination: Bloodlines opens on May 16. A final global gross of $330 to 350 million is predicted by analysts, making it a contender for awards season and the biggest original horror movie since A Quiet Place.
Conclusion: A Victory for Original Cinema
Sinners has surpassed Captain America: Brave New World domestically and held its own against Thunderbolts, making it 2025’s biggest box office success story in a year dominated by franchises. The power of original storytelling in an IP-driven era is demonstrated by its historic milestones, which range from record-breaking openings to historically low drop-offs. In addition to defying the Avengers, Ryan Coogler and Michael B. Jordan have created a vampire film that will go down in history as a box office success.
